Blog Layout

Kitchen Islands: Match Or Contrast During Remodel?

Derek Obringer • November 14, 2023

If you're considering a kitchen remodel for your Pittsburgh home, chances are you've already started thinking about the design of your new kitchen. One element that is becoming increasingly popular is the addition of a kitchen island. Not only does it add functionality to your space, but it also serves as a focal point and can enhance the overall aesthetic of your kitchen.

But with so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right kitchen island for your home. One aspect that often causes hesitation is whether to match your kitchen island to the rest of your kitchen or contrast it. In this article, we'll explore the various factors to consider when making this decision.

Benefits of Incorporating an Island into The Kitchen Design

Before we dive into the debate of matching or contrasting, let's first understand why incorporating a kitchen island in your design is beneficial.

Additional Storage: One of the main reasons people choose to add an island to their kitchen is for the extra storage space it provides. From pots and pans to small appliances, an island can have built-in cabinets and drawers that help declutter your kitchen.

Increased Counter Space: In a busy kitchen, having enough counter space is crucial. A kitchen island can provide you with additional surface area for meal prep, serving, and even seating.

Multi-Functional: Kitchen islands are extremely versatile and can serve multiple purposes in your kitchen. From being a cooking station to a breakfast bar or even a homework area for your kids, the possibilities are endless.

Designing Your Kitchen Island

There are several elements to consider when designing your ideal kitchen island, including:

Size and Orientation

First and foremost, you need to determine the size and orientation of your kitchen island. This will largely depend on the layout and size of your kitchen. If you have a smaller kitchen, you may opt for a smaller island more in line with the rest of your cabinetry. In this case, matching your island to the rest of your kitchen can create a cohesive look.

On the other hand, if you have a larger kitchen with ample space, you may want to consider a larger, more unique island. This is where the decision to contrast your island can make a statement. A contrasting island in a bold color or different material can add visual interest and break up the monotony of an all-matching kitchen.

Shape and Features

The shape and features of your kitchen island are also important factors to consider when deciding whether to match or contrast. A traditional rectangular island may lend itself more toward a matching design, while a curved or asymmetrical island may look better as a contrasting piece.

Additionally, the features of your kitchen island, such as built-in appliances or a sink, can also influence your decision. For example, if you have chosen a stainless steel refrigerator and range in your kitchen, a matching stainless steel island can tie the whole look together. On the other hand, a contrasting wooden or marble island can add warmth and texture to an otherwise modern kitchen.

Cabinetry and Paint

The cabinetry and paint of your kitchen island should also be considered when deciding whether to match or contrast. In general, if you have chosen to have different colored cabinets in your kitchen, a matching island can help create a cohesive look. If you have opted for all-white cabinetry, a contrasting island in a bold color or natural wood can add character and depth.

Similarly, the paint color of your kitchen island should complement the rest of your kitchen. A matching color or coordinating shade can seamlessly transition between the two areas. Alternatively, a contrasting color can add an unexpected pop of color and personality.

Countertop Options

Finally, let's talk about countertop options. Matching your kitchen island to the rest of your countertops is a classic choice and can create a clean and streamlined look. However, a contrasting countertop on your island can add dimension and texture to your space. This is particularly effective if you have chosen a neutral color palette for your kitchen.

Should I Match or Contrast My Island to the Rest of My Kitchen?

Ultimately, whether to match or contrast your kitchen island comes down to personal preference and the overall design of your kitchen. If you want a cohesive look, matching is the way to go. However, if you want to make a statement and add visual interest, contrasting can be an effective choice.

A few of the ways you can contrast are through the use of color, material, shape, and features. Try a contrasting paint color to serve as an accent and help the island stand out among the kitchen cabinetry.

In addition to adding a pop of color, you can also use a lighter color countertop or paint to contrast with your existing, darker countertops or paint colors.

If you want a more cohesive look, consider monochrome colors for your kitchen island. Look at your current kitchen color and choose lighter or darker shades of that color to create your island.

Should I DIY My Kitchen Island or Work With a Professional Kitchen Remodeler?

While it may be tempting to save money and build your kitchen island yourself, working with a professional can ensure that your island is not only functional but also aesthetically pleasing. A professional contractor or designer can help you make the best decision when it comes to matching or contrasting your kitchen island, as well as guide you through the entire design process.

Work with Obringer's Painting & Remodeling for Your Next Kitchen Remodeling Project

At Obringer's Painting & Remodeling, we specialize in kitchen remodeling in Pittsburgh and have years of experience creating functional and beautiful kitchen designs. Our team can help you choose the perfect kitchen island for your space, whether that means matching or contrasting. Contact us today to get started on your dream kitchen! So if you're looking for a professional partner in your kitchen remodel journey, look no further than Obringer's Painting & Remodeling. Our team will work with you to create a stunning and functional kitchen design that fits your style and budget.

So whether you choose to match or contrast your kitchen island, our experts at Obringer's Painting & Remodeling are here to bring your vision to life. Don't wait any longer; start your kitchen remodel in Pittsburgh today and elevate your cooking space to the next level!

< Older Post

Newer Post >

Author: Derek Obringer

Owner & Founder of Obringer's Painting and Remodeling, Derek Obringer brings attention to detail, together with experience, and superior customer service into each and every home that his company does work.

Painting And Remodeling Blog

General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodeling Contractors: Which One Do You Need?

By Derek Obringer • March 27, 2025

General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodelers: Key Differences When planning your kitchen renovation, choosing the right professional is crucial. Should you hire a general contractor or a kitchen remodeling contractor ? While both handle renovations, their expertise and scope of work differ significantly. General Contractors General contractors oversee large-scale remodeling projects, such as whole-home renovations or additions. They handle structural changes, electrical and plumbing work, and permit approvals. Because they manage multiple subcontractors and coordinate various trades, hiring a general contractor is typically more expensive. They are best suited for projects that go beyond just the kitchen. Kitchen Remodeling Contractors Kitchen remodelers specialize in kitchen-specific renovations, focusing on layout, design, and materials. They often work directly on the kitchen, rather than overseeing multiple subcontractors. Because their expertise is limited to one area of the home, they provide more cost-effective solutions for homeowners looking to upgrade their kitchens without altering other spaces. Which One Do You Need? If your project involves multiple rooms or structural changes, a general contractor is the best choice. However, if your renovation is kitchen-focused and you want a more budget-friendly approach, a kitchen remodeling contractor is the way to go. Understanding these differences can help you make the right decision for your home renovation needs. Key Differences: General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodelers When planning a home renovation, it's essential to understand the key differences between general contractors and kitchen remodelers to ensure you hire the right professional for the job. While both play crucial roles in home improvement, their scope of work, expertise, cost, and project management styles vary significantly. 1. Scope of Work The primary difference between a general contractor and a kitchen remodeler is the scope of work they handle: General Contractors: General contractors oversee broad renovation projects that may involve multiple rooms, entire home remodels, or structural changes. Their responsibilities often include: Managing large-scale renovations, including home expansions and floor plan modifications. Overseeing structural changes such as removing walls or adding new rooms. Coordinating various subcontractors, such as electricians, plumbers, and carpenters, to complete the project efficiently. Kitchen Remodelers: Kitchen remodelers, on the other hand, specialize exclusively in kitchen renovations. Their work is focused on: Optimizing kitchen layout design for better functionality and efficiency. Installing cabinetry, countertops, backsplashes, and appliances. Choosing the best materials, finishes, and storage solutions for an aesthetically pleasing and practical kitchen. If your project involves multiple rooms or structural modifications, a general contractor is necessary. However, if your focus is solely on updating or redesigning the kitchen, a kitchen remodeler is the better choice. 2. Expertise & Specialization The level of expertise required for a renovation depends on the type and complexity of the project. General Contractors: These professionals have broad knowledge across multiple trades, including: Structural modifications (e.g., knocking down walls or adding load-bearing beams). Electrical and plumbing work to support home expansions. Permitting and building code compliance for large-scale projects. Kitchen Remodelers: In contrast, kitchen remodelers focus specifically on kitchen design, materials, and functionality, which includes: Understanding the latest kitchen trends and space-saving solutions. Customizing cabinets, countertops, and islands for improved workflow. Ensuring optimal appliance placement to enhance efficiency. If your renovation requires significant structural changes, a general contractor is the right choice. However, if you want a kitchen tailored to your lifestyle and design preferences, a kitchen remodeler's specialized knowledge is more beneficial. 3. Cost Considerations Cost is a major factor when choosing between a general contractor and a kitchen remodeler. General Contractor: In most cases, they will charge a percentage of the total project cost, often ranging between 10% and 25%. Their services are more expensive due to the larger scale of work and involvement of multiple trades. Costs may include permits, labor for structural changes, and extensive material selections. Kitchen Remodeling Company: Offer a more budget-friendly option for homeowners focusing solely on the kitchen. Since they specialize in one area, their labor and material costs are often more predictable and controlled. Homeowners can choose from different levels of renovation, from minor upgrades to high-end, custom kitchen designs. If you're planning a whole-home remodel or structural work, a general contractor's higher costs are justified. However, if you need a cost-effective kitchen transformation, a kitchen remodeler is the smarter financial choice. 4. Project & Subcontractor Management Managing a renovation project requires careful coordination, and the approach differs between general contractors and kitchen remodelers. General Contractor: Act as project manager, hiring and overseeing subcontractors for various tasks such as flooring, plumbing, and HVAC installation. Ensure all trades work in sync to meet project deadlines. Handle any unexpected construction challenges, such as hidden electrical issues or outdated plumbing. Kitchen Remodeling Company: Typically, they work with a smaller, more specialized team of designers and craftsmen. Provide a hands-on approach by focusing on specific kitchen elements, ensuring quality control throughout the project. May still work with subcontractors (e.g., electricians or plumbers) but on a much smaller scale than general contractors. If your renovation involves multiple professionals across different areas, a general contractor is necessary. However, if you prefer a more direct and focused approach for your kitchen, a kitchen remodeler provides the expertise needed. Both general contractors and kitchen remodelers bring valuable skills to the table, but their expertise is suited for different types of projects. Why Choose Obringer's Painting & Remodeling? When it comes to kitchen renovations, you need a team with experience, craftsmanship, and a commitment to customer satisfaction. Obringer's Painting & Remodeling stands out as a trusted name in the industry, offering: Expert Kitchen Design & Craftsmanship: From modern updates to timeless styles, our team specializes in creating stunning, functional kitchen spaces tailored to your needs. Quality Materials & Workmanship: We use only high-quality materials, ensuring your kitchen remodel stands the test of time. Affordable, Transparent Pricing: We provide clear estimates with no hidden costs, helping you get the best value for your investment. Personalized Service & Attention to Detail – Every project is handled with care, and we work closely with homeowners to bring their vision to life. Timely Project Completion: Our team is dedicated to finishing projects efficiently without sacrificing quality so you can enjoy your new kitchen sooner. Call Obringer's Today for Your Next Kitchen Remodel! Ready to transform your kitchen? Contact Obringer's Painting & Remodeling today for a consultation with a kitchen renovation expert who can bring your vision to life. Whether you're making small updates or planning a complete remodel, our team is here to deliver exceptional results with expert craftsmanship and outstanding service. Let's create the kitchen of your dreams!